November 23rd, 2008 Posted in Grievances, Reading Notes | 1 Comment »
After a couple months sans Twilight-saga material, I decided to download the partial draft of Midnight Sun from Stephenie Meyer’s Web site. Midnight Sun is the Twilight story told from Edward Cullen’s perspective.
The backstory of the Midnight Sun scandal, for those who don’t know, is that Meyer’s draft was leaked to the internet at some point during the taping of Twilight the movie. In response to this invasion of rights and privacy, Meyer shelved the novel “indefinitely.” She has since named it as her next project, according to recent updates to her Web site.
I liked what I read of the draft, which was the first twelve chapters of the novel-in-progress. The story takes you right up to Edward and Bella’s trip to the circular meadow before ending. Admittedly, I was a bit disappointed that she didn’t include just one more chapter so that I could have read the meadow scene from Edward’s p.o.v. I wonder if Meyer had that chapter written and just didn’t include it in order to drum up more interest for the future novel?
I had read earlier, from various sources, that Edward saw himself as a monster–one not worthy of Bella’s adoration. In Twilight, this aspect of his character was minimally addressed. In Midnight Sun however, it is predominant. After Edward has fallen in love with Bella, he is consumed with finding a way to leave her so that she will never have to be victim to the monster within him. Of course, he becomes her protector and can’t make himself leave.
One of the things I wanted out of the Twilight saga but didn’t get was physical passion. As you may have read in some of my earlier posts about the books, I was disappointed that Meyer left out some much-wanted details about Edward and Bella’s love life. I found in Edward’s version that there was a bit more talk about the physical attraction to Bella and hints to the effects it had on Edward. Maybe she felt with the story coming from a male perspective that it was more appropriate to talk about. Whatever the reason, I appreciated that she kept it real. I wish I could have gotten a peek at that next chapter to see how Meyer handled the scene in the meadow where Bella and Edward have their first real physical connection. It would be a good indication of how the topic in the rest of the novel would be addressed.
I definitely don’t want the repetition of the entire Twilight saga rewritten in Edward’s perspective, but I am looking forward to Midnight Sun’s release. If you’re interested in reading what there is of Midnight Sun, you can find it here.
Now to digress a little…
A tweet from a writer I follow on Twitter left me miffed yesterday. As you probably know, Twilight the movie came out on Friday. It has been a common topic on Twitter since then. The writer said, “Whenever a book like Twilight gets popular, a piece of me dies. When it’s made into a film, that dead piece returns as a zombie to kill me.” Okay, so I see the humor in it. It’s the whole reason I chose to follow the guy in the first place; he’s usually pretty funny. But, it’s what he’s implying that got me. It had been too long since the tweet to reply and not feel stupid, so I didn’t bother. I probably would have said something like, “Who are you to judge what people like to read, you snob!”
When he said “a book like Twilight” I assume he’s referring to the arguably low-brow writing of the young adult fantasy/sci-fi genre. If you look back at my first couple posts about Twilight, you’ll see that I complained about the writing. I understand that y.a. fiction isn’t always the most intellectual or literarily important, but that doesn’t make it worthless. When I was in that age range, I loved those books. My genre of choice was “thriller” by the likes of Christopher Pike and R. L. Stine. Sure, I wasn’t learning grand worldly ideas or expanding my vocabulary, but I was reading and enjoying it. There is a time and place for literary fiction, but otherwise, reading is reading. Don’t complain about the types of books young adults are reading, and be happy that they are. Book tastes are like any others. Gary Vaynerchuk, for instance, would argue that wine is only as good as you think it is. You have to trust your own palate. So it is with books. If y.a. fiction isn’t you’re thing, just don’t read it.